← General Discussion

[Safety Testing] What Happens to an Image? Part 2

under review

An illustration of the "Modified Submit Button" solution to the image-scanning problem.

Image will be uploaded or pasted and appear to the user as desired in the WYSIWYG editor.
On Submit, content would be edited to replace any `<img src=".."/>` tags with a known "Your image is being scanned" replacement image URI.
After the Post/Comment is created, a Custom Object is created with the Post Id, Comment Id, URIs, etc.
ZIS and/or EventBridge is required to invoke a callback to Safety Service. Authentication may include ZIS OAuth Config.
Images are only deleted when the Post/Comment that 'owns' the initial image upload is deleted. Posts/Comments can be added on behalf of other users.
Example Editor Before Submit:
Example Post after Submit:
Example Post after Scanned: Cleared:

Registered User shared this idea

June 02, 2022 18:08
Edited
Report a Concern

12 Comments

Post a new comment:

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Date Votes

Sorted by oldest

Official comment
Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 04, 2022 22:38

Edited

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
This is an 'official' comment.

https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/QUsgyQ3Qpdzqozhjd8w8SA.png
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 19:28

Edited

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
This is not an 'official' comment.

(Any comment can be 'official', but only one comment at a time.)

https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/272M93bMSXPEcdYLCoeMNg.png
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 18:52

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
Adding this comment (A) with an image (I) that will be referenced in another comment (B), after which (B) will be deleted.

This is supposed to result in the Image being deleted.

This should result in Comment (A) having a broken image.

Here is the image (a dancing baby groot):

The image URL (before submitting):
https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/4bu_bRVO-XWueLKU_Qbv2g.gif

Registered User commented

May 05, 2022 18:55
Edited
Report a Concern
Comment actions Permalink

This comment contains the raw JSON of the prior Comment (A).

        {
            "id": 6028599759117,
            "body": "<p>Adding this comment (A) with an image (I) that will be referenced in another comment (B), after which (B) will be deleted.</p>\n<ul>\n<li>This is supposed to result in the Image being deleted.</li>\n<li>This should result in Comment (A) having a broken image.</li>\n<li>Here is the image <em>(a dancing baby groot)</em>:&nbsp;<br><img src=\"https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/4bu_bRVO-XWueLKU_Qbv2g.gif\">\n</li>\n<li>The image URL (before submitting):&nbsp;\n<pre>https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/4bu_bRVO-XWueLKU_Qbv2g.gif</pre>\n</li>\n</ul>",
            "author_id": 4640475840781,
            "vote_sum": 0,
            "vote_count": 0,
            "official": false,
            "html_url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/community/posts/6007486968461--Safety-Testing-What-Happens-to-an-Image-/comments/6028599759117",
            "created_at": "2022-05-05T18:52:13Z",
            "updated_at": "2022-05-05T18:52:13Z",
            "url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/api/v2/help_center/community/posts/6007486968461/comments/6028599759117.json",
            "post_id": 6007486968461,
            "non_author_editor_id": null,
            "non_author_updated_at": null
        }

Registered User commented

May 05, 2022 19:04
Report a Concern
Comment actions Permalink

This is the raw JSON of Comment (B), that was added with an image from Comment (A), and then was deleted via the API.

The Comment Body contained the same image URL as the previous Comment (A).
Even after deleting Comment (B), the image remains available at the URL from Comment (A)

        {
            "id": 6028714077325,
            "body": "<p>This is a new comment (B) with an image link from another comment (A).&nbsp;</p>\n<ul>\n<li>I pasted the src-link and the WYSIWYG editor rendered the image:<br><br><img src=\"https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/4bu_bRVO-XWueLKU_Qbv2g.gif\">\n</li>\n</ul>",
            "author_id": 4640475840781,
            "vote_sum": 0,
            "vote_count": 0,
            "official": false,
            "html_url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/community/posts/6007486968461--Safety-Testing-What-Happens-to-an-Image-/comments/6028714077325",
            "created_at": "2022-05-05T18:57:44Z",
            "updated_at": "2022-05-05T18:57:44Z",
            "url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/api/v2/help_center/community/posts/6007486968461/comments/6028714077325.json",
            "post_id": 6007486968461,
            "non_author_editor_id": null,
            "non_author_updated_at": null
        }

2

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 19:25

Edited

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
This is a screenshot of Comment (A) with the 'original' image URL.

The image still visible, after Comment (B) was deleted. It was only referenced here, not uploaded in Comment (B).

Screenshot:
1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 19:14

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
Comment (D)

Image from Comment (C), but only referenced via URL:

Image URL (before Submitting):

https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/LAkiDAMOq7r7kzajZzNfUg.png

Registered User commented

May 05, 2022 19:15
Report a Concern
Comment actions Permalink

Comment (C)'s raw JSON (before deleting it)

        {
            "id": 6029225554701,
            "body": "<p>Performing the same test, except this time will delete the 'original' Comment (C), as opposed to the one that references the already-uploaded image Comment (D).&nbsp;</p>\n<p><strong>Comment (C)</strong></p>\n<ul>\n<li>Image <em>(\"it just works\")</em>: <br><img src=\"https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/LAkiDAMOq7r7kzajZzNfUg.png\">\n</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Image URL (before submitting):</p>\n<pre>https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/user_images/LAkiDAMOq7r7kzajZzNfUg.png</pre>\n<p>&nbsp;</p>",
            "author_id": 4640475840781,
            "vote_sum": 0,
            "vote_count": 0,
            "official": false,
            "html_url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/community/posts/6007486968461--Safety-Testing-What-Happens-to-an-Image-/comments/6029225554701",
            "created_at": "2022-05-05T19:12:36Z",
            "updated_at": "2022-05-05T19:12:36Z",
            "url": "https://minecraftfeedback1526510002.zendesk.com/api/v2/help_center/community/posts/6007486968461/comments/6029225554701.json",
            "post_id": 6007486968461,
            "non_author_editor_id": null,
            "non_author_updated_at": null
        }

1

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 19:19

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
Screenshot of Comment (D) AFTER Comment (C) was deleted.

The previously-uploaded image is now broken as-expected.

Discovery: User-Uploaded Images are deleted only when the Post/Comment to which they were initially attached is Deleted.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

May 05, 2022 19:53

Edited

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
I attempted to add a Comment with a Public Image URL (not hosted on this Zendesk Subdomain), and received the following Error Toast:

The Image URL: https://techcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/fail-whale.png

Toast:

However, the Comment Editor had already been cleared and no Comment was actually submitted.

This appears to be a bug in the Editor, but ultimately it did not allow the comment to be added with a public URL, so this is a good thing.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

June 07, 2022 03:55

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
Super-magic test: This should get flagged because it's supercalifragilistic.

It also has an image tag.
0

Registered User commented

Comment actions Permalink

March 28, 2024 12:20

Report a Concern

Comment actions Permalink
Hi, this comment is posted for testing Sorting on March 28, 2024